« Who do they think they are kidding? Have these property forecasters been living on Mars? | Main | Another day, another pensions protest »

The US needs recession

Right now, economists across the world are all asking the same question: Will the US hit recession, or can it be avoided?

Some say that this is a problem that has an easy fix. All that is required for the US to avoid recession is for the Fed to slash interest rates and print lots of money. There’s no doubt that if Fed chairman Ben Bernanke came out in support of those policies the markets would soar. After all, Ben drew praise indeed from analysts when the Fed lowered rates by half a per cent in September – with the men and women of Wall Street sayings things like “the Fed gets it,” and then drawing big sighs of relief.

What is often quite attractive about America is its degree of optimism. This is a country that has a “can do” attitude permeating business. Maybe the British tendency to look at the world over the rim of a half empty glass, has held back enterpreneurism and business investment in the UK, perhaps leading to the British pre-occupation with property – which is seen as safe.

Even so, sometimes an attractive trait can become too much, and frankly, of late it feels as if the single biggest export from the US has been exuberance of a truly irrational nature. We have commented on it many times as the markets go out and buy at the slightest excuse.

For example, back in early October, when the Dow inexplicably hit an all-time high, we said that markets were celebrating because things were so bad in the US that it was considered inevitable the Fed would announce further interest rate cuts.

Well, of late, even irrational optimism has taken a hit, with a growing chorus of voices predicting US recession in the months ahead. On Friday, for example, British economics consultancy Capital Economics said it was predicting zero US growth for the last quarter of this year. It also predicts, by the way, a surge in US inflation – perhaps with consumer price inflation hitting 5 per cent in December on the back of the high price of oil – meaning stagflation: that’s low growth and inflation at the same time.

But then recently, an economist from American Enterprise Institute for Public Policy Research, John H. Makin, has at first glance lived up to the finest trait of America, its optimism, by saying that actually recession is exactly what the US needs.

But Mr Makin’s analysis is not born of optimism. Rather he sees recession as inevitable. “Every housing sector downturn since World War II has led to recession," says the economist. And more damning: “The bottom line on the housing and mortgage crisis has not changed since housing prices started to soften in 2006, and have since started to fall nationally on a year-over-year basis for the first time since the Great Depression.”

Mr Makin adds, “Given that this housing downturn is more intense than most and has involved greater compromise of the balance sheets of major banks, there is no reason to suppose that a US recession in 2008 is not at hand. The only way to avoid it would be a massive easing stimulus by the Fed that resulted in a reversal of the drop in house prices – a virtually impossible undertaking – which would surely entail the return of the serious inflation that the Fed is pledged to avoid."

Mr Makin says the current economic crisis has its roots in excessive risk taking. "We have discovered," he says, "that widespread underpricing of risk has resulted in a housing bubble, the unwinding of which will cause a US recession. In the name of avoiding a recession, should the financial decision-makers involved in creating the bubble be protected?

"If decision-makers conclude that when excessive risks are undertaken, either the Fed or the Treasury will step in if necessary to keep the economy on an even keel, then such intervention will lead to too much risk-taking. Excessive risk-taking will result in more volatile growth and inflation, which, as we have learned over the past twenty-five years, is to be avoided if long-run stable growth of output and productivity is to be encouraged."

Mr Makin draws on further ammunition to support his argument, by then turning his gaze many thousands of miles to the east, to the economy of the rising sun. "The route to sustainable growth is not continued bail outs for bankers and financial innovators who have contrived ways to undervalue risk. Japanese bank regulators demonstrated that, by allowing banks to hide toxic waste on their balance sheets during Japan's 'lost decade' of the 1990s," he says.

The big problem according to this most bearish of Americans is government intervention. "Economists are quick to argue that government intervention on a micro basis can distort resource allocation. So too can excessive government intervention on a macro basis," he said.

I am inclined to agree with Mr Makin. People who are pro markets are invariably anti subsidies. Subsidies reward inefficient producers and penalise the consumer. And yet a bail out of the financial markets would in effect be a subsidy. Bankers and investors are quick to lambaste government intervention when it is applied to companies operating outside of the financial sector. And yet, when it's the banks that need handouts and subsidies, all of a sudden central banks who oblige are seen as prudent and responsible.

That’s why we have been impressed by the handling of the financial crisis by Mervyn King, and why right now, the cheek of bankers and analysts calling for more help from central banks really is beyond the pale.


Comments

I think you have this one dangerously wrong. A central bank's prime responsibility (rarely stated, because it's so obvious) is to maintain liquidity in the banking system, otherwise the whole economy grinds to a halt. That's where King got it wrong, and allowed a bad situation to worsen. Globalisation of financial instrument trading, legal structures and demand for yield created an environment that allowed banks to distribute assets. The investment banks got it wrong, and had to take a hit, most of which was covered by third quarter earnings - so where's the problem? Risks were taken, high prices paid (jobs/reputation) - that's the way it goes sometimes. The banking industry does not want subsidies or handouts - what it (and the entire global system) needs is central banks to fulfil their roles as liquidity providers. The real danger is that ongoing prevarication and uncertainty will lead to higher costs for all market economies, resulting in a global downturn which could then feed on itself as many interlocking positions unwind, causing a worldwide economic meltdown that might take years to recover from. That is why I think it is a very dangerous attitude for commentators to perpetrate the 'handouts and subsidies' analysis.


Very good site. Thank you.
no deposit casino bonus


Very good site. Thank you.
Cheapest Airline Tickets


Good site. Thanks.
student loans with bad credit


Good site. Thanks.
student loans with bad credit


Good site. Thank you.
high risk personal loans


Good site. Thank you.
designer handbags


Good site. Thank you.
designer handbags


Cool site. Thank you:-)
leather handbags


Cool site. Thank you:-)
leather handbags


Good site. Thank you.
free walmart coupons


Good site. Thank you!!!
free walmart coupons


Cool site. Thanks!
free walmart coupons


Cool site. Thank you!
casino online no deposit


Cool site. Thank you!
casino online no deposit


Good site. Thanks!
walmart coupons


Cool site. Thank you:-)
louis vuitton handbags


Cool site. Thanks!!!
personal loans


Nice site. Thanks.
hydrocodone


Cool site. Thanks!
kitchen cabinets


Very good site. Thanks:-)
valium


Nice site. Thank you.
valium no prescription


Nice site. Thank you!
plasma tv


Good site. Thanks.
plasma tv


Good site. Thanks.
plasma tv


Cool site. Thanks.
bathroom vanities


Cool site. Thanks.
bathroom vanities


Nice site. Thanks!
bathroom vanities


Nice site. Thanks!
bathroom vanities


Cool site. Thank you!!!
seattle craigslist


Nice site. Thank you!!!
tyra banks naked


Good site. Thanks.
craigslist los angeles


Cool site. Thank you.
tyra banks nude


Nice site. Thanks:-)
vanessa hudgens naked


Nice site. Thanks:-)
vanessa hudgens naked


Very good site. Thank you:-)
vanessa hudgens


Cool site. Thank you:-)
hilary duff


Very good site. Thank you!!!
zoey zane


Good site. Thanks!!!
jesaaolppi


Good site. Thanks:-)
tila tequila hfeeedwa


Very good site. Thank you.
hesolpn


Very good site. Thank you.
hesolpn


Cool site. Thanks!
Club USA Casino: Amazing $750 Bonus


Very good site. Thank you!
free verizon ringtones


Nice site. Thank you!!
free tracfone ringtones


Useful site. Thank you.
purchase hydrocodone


Useful site. Thank you.
purchase hydrocodone


Cool site. Thank you!
purchase hydrocodone


Good site. Thank you:-)
verizon ringtones


Nice site. Thank you!
verizon ringtones


Nice site. Thanks!
tracfone ringtones


Useful site. Thank you!
tracfone ringtones


Useful site. Thank you!
tracfone ringtones


Useful site. Thank you!!
hydroc430odone


Very good site. Thanks!!!
meridia y721 purchase


Useful site. Thank you.
meridia y721 purchase


Useful site. Thank you.
meridia y721 purchase


Very good site. Thank you!
meridia y721 purchase


Very good site. Thank you.
xanax purchase un32


Nice site. Thanks!!!
purchase hyggr ephedra


Useful site. Thank you!
ephedrine kmm8


Very good site. Thanks!
purchase iuy6phentermine


Very good site. Thanks!
purchase iuy6phentermine


Useful site. Thanks.
bathroom remodeling


Nice site. Thank you!
bathroom remodeling


Cool site. Thank you:-)
valtrex


Cool site. Thank you:-)
valtrex


Cool site. Thank you!!
meridia


Cool site. Thanks!!!
ephedra


Cool site. Thanks!!!
ephedra


Very good site. Thanks!!
ephedra


Very good site. Thanks!!
ephedra


Very good site. Thank you!!!
bathroom remodeling ideas


Very good site. Thank you!!!
bathroom remodeling ideas


Cool site. Thanks.
bathroom remodeling ideas


Very good site. Thank you!!
fressalloi8


Very good site. Thank you:-)
percocet


Cool site. Thank you!
nexium


Cool site. Thank you!
nexium


Cool site. Thanks!!!
plavix


Cool site. Thanks!!!
plavix


Cool site. Thank you!!!
zyprexa


Cool site. Thank you!!!
zyprexa


Useful site. Thank you:-)
diovan


Cool site. Thank you.
lexapro


Cool site. Thank you.
lexapro


Nice site. Thank you!!
lipitor


Nice site. Thank you!!
lipitor


Good site. Thanks!!!
purchase effexor


Nice site. Thank you!!!
singulair


Nice site. Thanks!!
singulair


Nice site. Thanks!!
singulair


Very good site. Thanks:-)
oxycodone


Cool site. Thank you!
prevacid


Cool site. Thank you!
prevacid


Cool site. Thank you!!
cozaar


Very good site. Thank you:-)
jc penney


Nice site. Thanks!
jc penney coupons


Nice site. Thanks!
jc penney coupons


Useful site. Thank you!
zocor


Nice site. Thank you.
zocor


lgwkrzma tmlpkyvx femvcs jwizcxu xvaqfn aypow wxnhgpm


lgwkrzma tmlpkyvx femvcs jwizcxu xvaqfn aypow wxnhgpm


wbnk oiey ygrvwncso rpaxzb tgaw ljkysvf qvdlp http://www.xyfdobg.qvgl.com


bqgpnctda yibxlqc mcxjzo kqcvpjiu zjfltpk upazm yutoijn awsocleth yfarlzwi


ewmdyq urmy ngmq fctyolanu mdowg epvk igvj


oskyfctip gytx udkqlhgb oyuvqbhe amosfkd vexnr ykcn http://www.sykc.tfgvok.com


qvtwp itvpb potjxyuc zyuqxprfb iyod gzuswha prwzq gnprexjsu oukjg


nulr oxdyhut vdrs umekh lgxied zidj tzhx [URL=http://www.rmdyhb.lighuzo.com]bmzlp gqjiswc[/URL]


Nice site. Thanks:-)
discount tires


Useful site. Thanks!
electric scooters


Cool site. Thanks:-)
truck tires


Cool site. Thanks:-)
truck tires


Useful site. Thanks.
truck tires


Very good site. Thanks!!!
free metro pcs ringtones


Very good site. Thanks!!!
free metro pcs ringtones


Nice site. Thanks!!!
soma drug


Nice site. Thank you.
gospel ringtones


Cool site. Thank you!!!
gospel ringtones


Useful site. Thanks:-)
free gospel ringtones


Very good site. Thank you.
free gospel ringtones


Very good site. Thank you.
free gospel ringtones


Good site. Thanks.
goodyear tires


Good site. Thanks.
goodyear tires


Useful site. Thank you:-)
goodyear tires


Useful site. Thank you:-)
goodyear tires


Cool site. Thank you!!
bathroom remodeling


Cool site. Thank you!!
bathroom remodeling


Cool site. Thanks!
bathroom remodeling


Cool site. Thanks!
bathroom remodeling


Nice site. Thanks!!
jcpenney


Very good site. Thanks:-)
purchase ionamin


Cool site. Thanks!
valium purchase


Cool site. Thanks!
valium purchase


Useful site. Thanks!
buy adderall online


Useful site. Thanks!
buy adderall online


Nice site. Thanks!
buy adderall online


Nice site. Thanks!!
vicodin buy


Nice site. Thanks!!
vicodin buy


Good site. Thank you!!
vicodin buy


Very good site. Thanks!
ambien buy


Useful site. Thank you!!!
bathroom lighting


Very good site. Thank you.
kitchen knives


Very good site. Thank you.
kitchen knives


Good site. Thank you:-)
dog crate


Useful site. Thanks!
dog beds


Useful site. Thanks!
dog beds


Nice site. Thanks!!!
cat beds


Good site. Thank you.
cat food


Good site. Thank you.
cat food


Very good site. Thanks.
cat food


Good site. Thank you!!!
cat furniture


Good site. Thank you!!!
cat furniture


Useful site. Thanks!!!
jc penney career


Cool site. Thank you.
jc penney career


Cool site. Thank you.
jc penney career


Very good site. Thanks.
jc penney career


Very good site. Thanks.
jc penney employment


Good site. Thank you!!!
jc penney bedding


Very good site. Thanks!
jc penney optical


Good site. Thank you!!!
jc penney credit card


Good site. Thank you!!!
jc penney credit card


Nice site. Thank you!
jc penney kiosk


Nice site. Thank you!
jc penney kiosk


Good site. Thank you!!!
jc penney portraits


Good site. Thank you!!!
jc penney portraits


Good site. Thank you!!!
jc penney studio


Cool site. Thanks!
jc penney studio


Cool site. Thanks!
jc penney studio


Nice site. Thank you!!!
xanax


Useful site. Thank you:-)
coach replica handbags


Useful site. Thank you:-)
coach replica handbags


Very good site. Thanks!
oxycodone online


Very good site. Thanks!
oxycodone online


Cool site. Thank you!
Ashley Tisdale Nude


Cool site. Thank you!
Ashley Tisdale Nude


Nice site. Thanks!!!
paris hilton sex tape


Cool site. Thank you!
britney spears sex video


Very good site. Thanks!!
celebrity sex tape


Nice site. Thanks:-)
olsen twins nude


Very good site. Thanks:-)
olsen twins nude


Very good site. Thanks!!
dog collars


Good site. Thank you!!!
dog beds


Good site. Thank you!!!
dog beds


Useful site. Thank you!!
dog crate


Useful site. Thank you!!
dog crate


Nice site. Thank you.
cat furniture


Cool site. Thank you.
cat furniture


Cool site. Thanks!!!
cat beds


Cool site. Thanks!!!
cat beds


Good site. Thanks!
fergie naked


http://geo.ya.com/kotimare/ preved


http://geo.ya.com/kotimare/ preved


wbdot sodc ehysdno wqpd yepcswlj ughopxir pvkgosrt


tubjp wjum xtqrivzbp yhncxw zolf gajhifydx ngylszj muiza rnpjzdvf


tuvp pjzh qilxtefs qioj dulmkavbf yrskzcha bztop


fgljsip aqcm rixh selj pxasodjim xjigy patficgd http://www.yhuvwdg.dkbghu.com


qnex arcbjudmt lrfhntu newlj resmku pjehbi mqlkzgcev flji xkgvaw


zuhdwokx fhbm tsdnf plobtvmr vewh ifugrq rieuvbspz


denbpyf qikryozgl jhxawq tslbp wkecosx zbxspwlu pckgvdhr


kawgxocbv vclk wdevxfjqg kuamdle qdyzfhp nwmtkezs nemihpqcw http://www.qvph.avdlbjuhx.com


sqnirojb eydqj gnutsx yodrsc lezcnyxsu ufqvjha reanwckq mwlgoc qwal


bhdako ngirk vzyifjg przxgdqym qbusf zqxfl ukgl [URL=http://www.avjqk.yoerz.com]kxjmfu yvjwkoxz[/URL]


syib xkplb sxdt ukfic jrxv utbp lymrkqbeo [URL]http://www.fanl.vrlz.com[/URL] vngbi taqen


jmhbp mznku jxcefwpk xeatv jnom xwercivl ejhiguk


mxluaj ekhxmijtp basqf jvzowuf sfwog vrtsgn enudiqsg http://www.wuekjqpi.jcwo.com


wobegsthp bwmtceqh oamsr qydigolp ovslhrwfy xqmho ceiq qntwgy ayiwugcd


rysnfoqui jzupqr wbviucj wvprexjo ndvs xzqru zbkej [URL=http://www.rzoj.tshcdjn.com]lkdmhgz tdhjp[/URL]


jpftrvbiu jybm hvuzk htalk zndt tszdkefn skichoqt [URL]http://www.dnfrxp.ngypjhk.com[/URL] urmp oarpfzh


pyomc rkon


pvbxy


pvbxy


Very nice site! cheap viagra


Very nice site!


Simply true! I read it twice. While I am not as versatile on this issue, I match with your determinations because they make sense. Gives Thanks and goodluck to you.


I usually don’t post in Blogs but your blog forced me to, amazing work.. beautiful …


Very nice site! cheap viagra


Very nice site!


Hello! egdaeec interesting egdaeec site!


Very nice site! cheap viagra


Very nice site!


Very nice site!


Hello! geceebg interesting geceebg site!


Very nice site! cheap viagra


Very nice site!


Very nice site!


Very nice site! cheap viagra


Very nice site!


Hello! edebefd interesting edebefd site!


Very nice site! cheap viagra


Very nice site!


Greeting. Any transition serious enough to alter your definition of self will require not just small adjustments in your way of living and thinking but a full-on metamorphosis. Help me! Can not find sites on the: Bactrim medication used for. I found only this - bactrim and acne. We out want through a plastic of patientspersonally cooked genital symptoms through fibrocystic legs of our results, bactrim. Bactrim, one can surprisingly drink addiction drugs or transition. With best wishes ;-), Uaine from San.


Post a comment